Marcus Allen and the Los Angeles Raiders: The Greatest Career Nobody Let Him Finish
Marcus Allen rushed for 191 yards in Super Bowl XVIII, including a 74-yard touchdown run that President Reagan called a “secret weapon” and Moscow reportedly demanded be dismantled. The Raiders won 38-9. Allen was named MVP. He was 23 years old and in his second NFL season. What followed that day – over the next decade – was one of the strangest, most wasteful situations any franchise has ever engineered against its own best player.
From Heisman to Silver and Black
Allen grew up in San Diego, played at Lincoln High School, and arrived at USC in 1978 as a blocking back. He didn’t start rushing until his junior year. When he finally got carries, he finished his 1981 senior season with 2,342 rushing yards – still the single-season college record at the time – and won the Heisman Trophy along with the Maxwell Award and the Walter Camp Award. He averaged 5.2 yards per carry over his four college seasons and scored 46 touchdowns total.
The Los Angeles Raiders took him 10th overall in the 1982 NFL Draft. In a strike-shortened season of just nine games, Allen ran for 697 yards, caught 38 passes, and was named AP Offensive Rookie of the Year. Eleven seasons with the Raiders followed. He was their leading rusher in every single one of the first seven.
What’s worth noting about that stretch: Allen was not just a runner. He led the Raiders in receptions in 1987 with 51 catches. That year the team used him as a receiver out of necessity – injuries, roster changes – and he simply adjusted. The idea that he was a one-dimensional back never matched reality. He was the most complete running back the Raiders had during that era, though the franchise seemed to forget this somewhere around 1988.
The 1985 Season – The Year Nobody Could Stop Him
1,759 rushing yards. 380 carries. 4.6 yards per carry. 11 rushing touchdowns. He also caught 67 passes for 555 yards and scored 3 more touchdowns through the air. Total: 14 touchdowns, 2,314 combined yards from scrimmage, which set the single-season record at the time for rushing and receiving yards combined.
The NFL named him league MVP. The AP named him Offensive Player of the Year. He was 25.
This is the season that gets overlooked in conversations about the Allen-Davis feud, and it shouldn’t be. Allen was visibly, statistically, the best player in professional football that year – not just the best back, not just the best Raider. The best player in the league. Davis had a player like that, and within three years he was benching him.
Super Bowl XVIII – The 74-Yard Run and What Surrounded It
January 22, 1984. Tampa Stadium. The Washington Redskins came in at 16-2 and were favored. Washington had averaged 33 points a game that season. The Raiders won 38-9.
Allen carried 20 times for 191 yards and two touchdowns. He also caught two passes for 18 yards. His yards-per-carry average for the game: 9.55. Jim Plunkett was the quarterback. The offensive line – anchored by Henry Lawrence at tackle – gave Allen enough creases to operate, but the 74-yard run in the third quarter wasn’t about the blocking. It was about Allen reading a play that had nowhere to go and finding somewhere.
The play was supposed to go left. The Redskins were there. Allen planted, cut right, Lawrence took out half the defensive line with one block, and Allen was through. Cornerback Darrell Green – one of the fastest players in the league – didn’t pick him up in time. Allen said afterward: “I felt someone grab me from behind, but I pulled away, and then there was an alley.” He crossed the goal line with 12 seconds left in the third quarter to make it 35-9. The game had already been decided, but the run made it permanent.
His 191 yards stood as the Super Bowl rushing record until Timmy Smith ran for 204 in Super Bowl XXII four years later. The 74-yard run is still second-longest in Super Bowl history. ESPN ranked it the 10th greatest moment across all Super Bowls played. Reagan’s postgame call to the locker room remains one of the more absurd things a sitting president has said about a football game, and Allen told the story with visible amusement for years afterward.
Allen was also the first player in NFL history to win an NCAA national championship (1978 at USC, as a freshman), a Heisman Trophy, a Super Bowl, and a Super Bowl MVP. Nobody has done it since.
The Al Davis Feud – What Actually Happened and What Nobody Can Prove
Somewhere between 1985 and 1987, Al Davis decided he didn’t want Marcus Allen on his football team. He just wouldn’t let him leave.
That’s not a rhetorical simplification. That is, as best as reporters and documentary filmmakers have been able to reconstruct it, what happened. Allen went from league MVP in 1985 to watching other backs get his carries, to arriving at training camp one year listed fourth on the depth chart. Fourth. Behind players who are not in the Hall of Fame, will never be in the Hall of Fame, and who Davis himself acquired specifically to take Allen’s snaps.
“I don’t think there’s been any great running back in the league that has ever had to share the position with that many great running backs,” Allen said in a 2012 NFL Films documentary. “There was a time that I came into camp fourth string. I’m in the Hall of Fame, by the way.”
Former Raiders executive Ron Wolf offered the clearest explanation anyone connected to the franchise has given: Davis felt at some point that Allen had become bigger than the Raiders as a brand, and Davis had trouble with that because, in his view, it was always about the team. That’s plausible. Davis was not a man who handled being outshone gracefully, and Allen – handsome, articulate, beloved in Los Angeles – was genuinely more famous than the franchise by the mid-1980s.
The other theory, given renewed attention by Murray Olderman’s book “Just Win, Baby: The Al Davis Story,” is that Davis disapproved of Allen’s social circle – specifically his relationship with O.J. Simpson and Simpson’s inner circle. Allen has never confirmed this. Davis never addressed it publicly. It sits there as the most scandalous possibility and also the least verifiable one.
What Allen did confirm, on national television, was that Davis told him directly he was going to “get” him – and then did. In December 1992, during halftime of a Monday Night Football game, Allen sat down with Al Michaels for a taped interview and said plainly: “He told me he was going to get me and he has.” He called the relationship “acrimonious at best.” He accused Davis of having a personal vendetta. He said Davis was trying to stop him from reaching the Hall of Fame by keeping him off the field and making teams believe he was finished. That interview ran during one of the most-watched sports broadcasts in the country. Davis’s response was not public.
The hard part of this story, the part that doesn’t fully add up, is why Davis kept Allen at all. If you believe Allen was a cancer – Davis used that word – why not trade him? Allen demanded a trade. Teams wanted him. Davis refused. He kept Allen on the roster, barely used him, and allowed the whole situation to fester publicly for years. If the goal was to devalue Allen, leaving him with the Raiders while restricting his carries made more sense than trading him and watching him succeed elsewhere. That’s the most cynical reading, and given what came next, it’s hard to dismiss.
Davis released Allen after the 1992 season. Allen signed with the Kansas City Chiefs – the Raiders’ division rival – and won AP Comeback Player of the Year in 1993, his first season in Kansas City. He was 33 years old. He played five more years and retired after 1997.
The Numbers Allen Finished With
Across 16 NFL seasons: 12,243 rushing yards on 3,022 carries, 5,411 receiving yards on 587 catches, 145 total touchdowns. At retirement he held the all-time record for rushing touchdowns with 123, a record that stood until Emmitt Smith passed him. He was the first player in NFL history to accumulate more than 10,000 rushing yards and 5,000 receiving yards in the same career.
His Raiders-specific numbers: 8,545 rushing yards, 4,258 receiving yards, 97 total touchdowns. The franchise’s all-time leading rusher. Five Pro Bowl selections as a Raider, a sixth with Kansas City in 1994. Two first-team All-Pro selections. The 1985 league MVP. The Super Bowl XVIII MVP.
He was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2003. He now works as a football analyst for CBS Sports.
The Reconciliation, and What Mark Davis Said
Al Davis died in October 2011. The following September, Allen returned to the Raiders’ stadium and lit the eternal flame honoring his former owner before a home game against the Pittsburgh Steelers. The Raiders won 34-31.
Mark Davis – Al’s son – said Allen’s return “meant a lot to my mom.” He also said: “Marcus was the absolute true Raider. There are very few football players I’ve seen like him, that worked that hard.”
Allen declined to comment through a Raiders spokesman. He didn’t need to say anything. Lighting a flame for a man who called you a cancer, who spent years trying to end your career, who refused to let you go when you begged him to – that’s a more complicated statement than any quote would be. Whether it was forgiveness or just the passage of time, only Allen knows. The hostility had simmered for nearly three decades. The man who generated it was gone. Allen showed up anyway.
Where Allen Stands Among the Greatest Raiders
The Raiders have put five offensive players in the Canton Hall of Fame from their Los Angeles era: Allen, Jim Plunkett (by association), Fred Biletnikoff, Art Shell, and Gene Upshaw. Howie Long went in from the defensive side. Of all of them, Allen’s individual body of work is the most decorated.
The argument for Allen as the greatest Raider ever is short: he’s the franchise’s all-time leading rusher, he won them a Super Bowl with the single greatest individual performance in Super Bowl history, he was the best player in the NFL in 1985, and he did it all while being systematically undermined by his own owner in the back half of his career. He won anyway. The Chiefs stint is the proof – he wasn’t declining when Davis sidelined him. He had four productive seasons in Kansas City after leaving, and won Comeback Player of the Year in the first of them, which is a remarkable thing to win at 33 when you’re theoretically on the back nine of your career.
Jim Otto played his entire career as a Raider and is the franchise’s all-time center. Howie Long was the better defensive player of his generation for a stretch in the mid-1980s. These are legitimate names. But for one player who did the most to define what the Raiders were during their Los Angeles peak, it’s Allen, and it’s not particularly close.
The irony Davis never acknowledged publicly: he built the team that won Super Bowl XVIII, drafted Allen, and then spent the better part of a decade trying to erase what Allen had made of the opportunity. The 74-yard run is on NFL highlight reels forever. Davis’s vendetta is a footnote to the career, not the other way around.
Comments