Herschel Walker and the Dallas Cowboys: How One Trade Built Three Super Bowls
The most important thing Herschel Walker ever did for the Dallas Cowboys happened after he left. On October 12, 1989, Dallas shipped him to Minnesota for five players and six draft picks. Those picks – filtered through Jimmy Johnson’s plan to cut every player the Vikings sent, triggering the conditional pick clauses – eventually became Emmitt Smith, Russell Maryland, Darren Woodson, and Kevin Smith. Three Super Bowls followed. Walker never played in one.
Before Dallas: What the Cowboys Were Actually Getting
When the USFL folded in 1986, Walker had already been a professional football player for three years, and his numbers in that league were almost absurd. He ran for over 5,500 yards across three seasons with the New Jersey Generals – Donald Trump’s team – was named league MVP in 1985, and was physically unlike most running backs the NFL had seen. Six-foot-one, 225 pounds, reportedly doing 1,500 sit-ups and 1,000 push-ups daily, no weight room required. He ran the 100 meters in 10.2 seconds in college. The Cowboys had drafted him in the fifth round of the 1985 NFL Draft, pick 114 overall, while he was still in the USFL. They were waiting.
His contract with Dallas was reportedly worth $5 million over five years. That was real money in 1986, and the Cowboys knew what they were buying: not just a running back, but a swiss army knife at a position that usually came in one configuration. What they couldn’t promise him was a functional team around him.
The Four Cowboys Seasons: Good Numbers, Bad Teams
Walker’s first season in Dallas, 1986, was a split arrangement with Tony Dorsett that satisfied nobody – not Walker, not Dorsett, and not the coaching staff under Tom Landry. Walker topped the Cowboys in receiving and finished close behind Dorsett in rushing. The team went 7-9.
1987 was Walker’s first full season as the lead back, and he delivered. He led the entire NFL in yards from scrimmage with 1,606 – 891 rushing, 715 receiving – while playing in a strike-shortened 12-game season and being deployed at three different positions at once. He complained about it to management. Dorsett demanded a trade and got one, shipped to Denver. Walker was officially the guy now, on a team still sliding toward irrelevance.
Then came 1988. It was his best NFL season, and one of the more unusual statistical performances in Cowboys history. He rushed for 1,514 yards, caught 53 passes for 505 more, totaling 2,019 yards from scrimmage. That made him the 10th player in NFL history to crack 2,000 combined yards. He played seven different offensive positions that year – halfback, fullback, tight end, H-back, wide receiver in the slot, wide receiver as a flanker, and a couple of variations in between. Both Pro Bowls of his career came in 1987 and 1988. He received second-team All-Pro honors both seasons. The Cowboys went 3-13.
His 1988 numbers were genuinely impressive. In 81 career games with Dallas across both stints, he finished with 818 carries for 3,491 rushing yards and 35 touchdowns. The 1988 season alone accounts for nearly half those rushing yards. What doesn’t show up in the stats is how often he was the only competent piece on the field – Carl Banks of the New York Giants told reporters that Walker gave full effort every down even as things fell apart around him, but that with Dallas, the structure just wasn’t there to let him be what he could be.
The 1989 season lasted four games for Walker in a Cowboys uniform. Dallas was 0-4 under new head coach Jimmy Johnson, who had replaced the legendary Tom Landry in the offseason. The team would finish 1-15. Johnson reportedly came up with the idea to trade Walker on a morning jog with his staff, four games into the season. His logic was blunt: Walker was the only asset on the roster that any other team would pay real money for. Johnson briefly considered trading Michael Irvin to the Los Angeles Raiders – Al Davis talked him out of it – and came back around to Walker.
October 12, 1989: How the Trade Actually Worked
The deal the Cowboys and Vikings announced that day looked, on paper, like Minnesota won. Dallas sent Walker plus four late-round picks to the Vikings. In return, the Cowboys received five players – linebacker Jesse Solomon, linebacker David Howard, cornerback Issiac Holt, defensive end Alex Stewart, and running back Darrin Nelson – along with six conditional draft picks including a first- and second-rounder.
Dallas media panned it. The assumption was that the Vikings had landed a top-five running back coming off 2,000-yard seasons while the Cowboys received rotational depth and speculative picks. What everyone initially missed was the conditional structure buried in the agreement. Each player came attached to a draft pick escalator: if Dallas cut the player before the start of the following season, Minnesota would owe a higher-round compensatory selection. This wasn’t a side clause – it was, by Johnson’s own account, the entire point of the deal.
Darrin Nelson refused to report to Dallas and was sent to San Diego as a third team entered the transaction. That created additional pick movement. By the time the Cowboys had cut every player acquired from Minnesota – which is exactly what happened – the pick haul had grown to three first-round selections, three second-rounders, a third, and a sixth. The largest trade in NFL history, by total players and picks involved, eventually touched 18 players and three franchises.
Vikings general manager Mike Lynn structured the deal this way, apparently not grasping how badly the conditional escalators would bite. That’s the part that doesn’t fully add up even now: Lynn was an experienced executive. The Cowboys were openly in rebuild mode. Whether he didn’t read the fine print or believed strongly enough in Walker that he thought the risk was manageable – nobody has given a satisfying answer to that.
What the Cowboys Did With Eighteen Players’ Worth of Future
The three first-round picks went to work immediately. The 1990 first-rounder became Emmitt Smith, drafted 17th overall out of Florida. Smith retired as the NFL’s all-time leading rusher with 18,355 yards. The 1991 first-rounder was Russell Maryland, a dominant defensive tackle. A 1992 first-rounder helped Dallas trade up for other pieces. Darren Woodson arrived as a second-round pick and became one of the best safeties in Cowboys history, a three-time Super Bowl champion and six-time Pro Bowl selection. Kevin Smith came from another second-rounder and started at cornerback for the dynasty teams.
Dallas also used the accumulated capital as currency in subsequent trades with Pittsburgh, New England, Atlanta, Houston, and San Francisco – stockpiling more picks and acquiring players who filled out a roster that, in 1989, had almost nothing worth keeping. The Cowboys won Super Bowls after the 1992, 1993, and 1995 seasons. They did it with a quarterback (Troy Aikman), a receiver (Michael Irvin), a running back (Smith), and a secondary (including Woodson) built almost entirely from the assets that came from trading one running back who had posted 2,000 scrimmage yards the year before.
Smith is the clearest line between that October trade and those three Lombardi Trophies. He replaced Walker in the backfield so completely that it’s easy to forget what Walker had actually done in Dallas. Smith rushed for over 1,400 yards in each of his first four healthy seasons. He ran behind an offensive line Walker never had. The Cowboys’ running game from 1991 through 1996 looked like a different sport than what Dallas had asked Walker to carry in 1987 and 1988.
The Vikings Weren’t Foolish – They Were Wrong
Minnesota had won at least a divisional playoff game in each of the previous three seasons. They had a real team. Walker coming off back-to-back Pro Bowls and 2,000 scrimmage yards looked like the missing piece for a Super Bowl push in Minneapolis – and that’s how most observers framed it at the time. Sports Illustrated agreed with the Vikings in its immediate coverage. The Dallas press wrote the Cowboys off as having been fleeced.
Walker gained 669 rushing yards in the 1989 regular season with Minnesota. The Vikings lost in the first round of the playoffs. They missed the postseason entirely in 1990 and 1991. Walker was released after the 1991 season having rushed for just over 1,000 yards in his best Viking year, 1989. He never approached those 1988 Dallas numbers again. After eight more NFL seasons following the trade – with Philadelphia, New York, and his return to Dallas – he crossed 1,000 rushing yards only once more.
Whether the Vikings’ offensive line was the problem, or the system, or something harder to name – Walker post-trade was a different player. That’s also worth naming honestly: the deal didn’t just fail for Minnesota because of the picks. It failed because Walker didn’t perform the way they’d expected him to. Two things went wrong at once.
He Came Back to Dallas – and Almost Nobody Remembers It
In July 1996, the Cowboys signed Walker again. He was 34. He spent two seasons in Dallas as a third-down back and kick returner, exactly the kind of veteran specialist role that suits a player with his speed but not the same starting-caliber production. His most memorable play from that second stint: an 89-yard kickoff return in 1996, the longest play the Cowboys had that season. Still had the speed. Still made the secondary look slow. He retired after the 1997 season, ending his career in the same city where his NFL career had started.
In between – and this gets overlooked entirely in the trade coverage – Walker competed in the 1992 Winter Olympics in Albertville, France as a member of the United States bobsled team. He and his partner Brian Shimer finished seventh in the two-man event. He’d been selected originally for the four-man team and moved to the two-man competition. He was 30 years old, in the middle of an active NFL career, and placed seventh at the Winter Olympics in a sport he’d taken up relatively recently. There are not many people that sentence applies to.
The Hall of Fame Question Isn’t Going Away
Walker is in the College Football Hall of Fame, inducted in 1999. He’s not in Canton. At the time of his retirement, he trailed only Walter Payton in all-purpose yards in NFL history. His all-time all-purpose yards rank 12th when counted across the NFL alone. Factor in his USFL numbers – which the Pro Football Hall of Fame does not officially count – and he led all of professional football history in that category. Two Pro Bowls. Back-to-back All-Pro second teams. Led the league in scrimmage yards and rushing in consecutive seasons.
The counter-argument isn’t weak. His peak as an NFL player ran three seasons – 1987, 1988, and 1989 – and he never matched those numbers again after the trade. Zero first-team All-Pro selections. His career rushing total of 8,225 yards ranks outside the top 20 all-time. Voters looking at the ballot see two Pro Bowls and a single team All-Pro year when contemporaries like Eric Dickerson or Barry Sanders give them more to work with. The USFL omission genuinely distorts his case, but that’s been the Hall’s position since the league folded. His football career was exceptional. Whether it clears the Hall’s threshold depends almost entirely on whether you think those three first-round picks, and everything they became, should count in his favor – which is a question the voters haven’t had to answer yet, and don’t seem eager to.
Comments