Shaun Alexander and the Seattle Seahawks: From Florence, Kentucky to the Only MVP in Franchise History
A Kid from Kentucky Who Was Supposed to Be a Sure Thing
Shaun Alexander was the No. 1 high school football prospect in the country coming out of Boone County High School in Florence, Kentucky. Not top five. First. He finished his senior season with 3,166 rushing yards and 54 touchdowns. Those are numbers that don’t happen at the high school level without people noticing, and ESPN noticed. He also ran for 2,401 yards and 42 touchdowns the year before that. By the time he enrolled at Alabama in 1996, the expectations were already absurd – and he immediately justified them, rushing for 291 yards and four touchdowns against LSU as a freshman, which still stands as the Alabama single-game record.
He left Tuscaloosa as the school’s all-time leading rusher with 3,565 career yards and 50 touchdowns. The Seahawks selected him 19th overall in the 2000 NFL Draft with a pick they’d acquired from Dallas in the Joey Galloway trade. In hindsight, Seattle got the better end of that deal by a significant margin.
His rookie season was quiet. Ricky Watters was still the starter, and Alexander finished with just 64 carries for 313 yards and two touchdowns. Mike Holmgren later admitted he probably should have turned to Alexander earlier. He didn’t. But once the opportunity came in 2001, Alexander made the wait look irrelevant.
266 Yards, Five Touchdowns in a Half, and a Franchise Taking Shape
On November 11, 2001, Alexander ran for 266 yards on 35 carries against the Oakland Raiders. He also took an 88-yard run to the end zone that night. It’s still the Seahawks’ single-game rushing record more than two decades later. He was named NFC Offensive Player of the Week. The performance wasn’t a fluke – it was a signal. He’d finish that year with 1,318 yards and 14 touchdowns, second only to Marshall Faulk in total touchdowns across the league.
Then came September 29, 2002, in the second regular-season game ever played at what was then called Seahawks Stadium. Alexander scored five touchdowns in the first half against the Minnesota Vikings. Five. In one half. It’s an NFL record that still stands. He scored 16 rushing touchdowns that entire season, which led the NFC and broke the franchise record at the time.
The offensive line in front of him during these years was genuinely special. Walter Jones at left tackle was already one of the best in the league – he’d make the Hall of Fame. Steve Hutchinson at left guard was an All-Pro. Robbie Tobeck at center. Jones described the unit plainly: “We felt like there was nobody who could stop us. They knew what play we were running but they couldn’t stop us.” That context matters for understanding what came next, and it matters for the Hall of Fame argument that comes up later.
Building Four NFC West Titles in Five Years
From 2003 through 2005, Alexander went to three straight Pro Bowls. In 2004 he earned second-team All-Pro honors and came within one yard of the NFL rushing title. The Seahawks won the NFC West that season and made the playoffs for the third straight year. The team Holmgren built during this stretch – Alexander carrying the ball, Matt Hasselbeck managing the offense, Jones and Hutchinson clearing lanes – was as consistent an NFC contender as anyone outside of Philadelphia during those years, and they didn’t get nearly the national attention they deserved for it.
Alexander has said repeatedly that the thing he’s most proud of isn’t any individual stat. It’s the culture shift. “We win four NFC West titles in a row, go to the playoffs five years in a row. It created the culture that this is a winning town.” Before Holmgren arrived in 1999, the Seahawks had won one division title in their entire history. Alexander and his teammates won four straight.
The 2005 Season: 1,880 Yards, 28 Touchdowns, and One MVP Award
By the summer of 2005, the Seahawks had franchise-tagged Alexander rather than giving him a long-term deal. He’d been elite for four years and come within a yard of a rushing title the previous season. He had something to prove about his value, or at least something to make undeniable. What followed was one of the most dominant single seasons a running back has ever produced.
He ran for 1,880 yards on 370 carries. He scored 27 rushing touchdowns and 28 total, setting an NFL single-season record that broke Priest Holmes’s mark. He topped 100 rushing yards in 11 of Seattle’s 16 regular-season games. The Seahawks went 13-3 and won the NFC West. On January 5, 2006, Alexander was named NFL MVP – the first Seahawk to win the award, beating Tiki Barber and Peyton Manning, who had won it the two previous years. He got 19 of a possible 50 votes.
Some specific games from that season are worth naming because the cumulative numbers don’t fully capture how consistent the destruction was. He had two four-touchdown games – one against Arizona on September 25 and one against Houston on October 16. He ran 88 yards for a touchdown against the Cardinals in November. He rushed for 165 yards against the Rams. On December 18 against the Titans, he recorded his 10th 100-yard game of the season, a Seahawks franchise record. When he set the single-season touchdown record at 28 in the Week 17 game against Green Bay, he also tied Holmes’s record of 27 rushing touchdowns.
Jones’s description of blocking for Alexander that year: “Some people don’t understand Shaun had an All-Pro fullback too. Shaun knew, all I gotta do is make the safety miss and now I’m off to the races.” Mack Strong was that fullback, and he rarely gets mentioned in discussions about what made 2005 work. Jones made Hall of Fame blocks. Hutchinson pulled. Strong cleared. Alexander hit holes that were already open and then made the safety miss. That’s how it actually worked, and there’s nothing diminishing about acknowledging it – most great running backs don’t have a line that good.
The Seahawks beat the Carolina Panthers in the NFC Championship Game, with Alexander carrying 34 times for 132 yards and two touchdowns. It was easily the best playoff performance of his career. In Super Bowl XL against the Pittsburgh Steelers, he finished as the game’s leading rusher with 95 yards on 20 carries. Seattle lost 21-10. The officiating was widely criticized, and a horse-collar tackle by Joey Porter on Alexander late in the game drew no flag. None of that changed the final score. The season still stands as the best in Seahawks offensive history.
The Seahawks Franchise Records Alexander Still Owns
He hasn’t played for Seattle since 2007. These are still his records.
Career rushing attempts: 2,176. Career rushing yards: 9,429. Career rushing touchdowns: 100. Total career touchdowns: 112. Single-season rushing yards: 1,880 (2005). Single-season carries: 370 (2005). Single-season rushing touchdowns: 27 (2005). Single-season total touchdowns: 28 (2005). Single-game rushing yards: 266 (vs. Oakland, 2001). Single-game rushing touchdowns in a half: 5 (vs. Minnesota, 2002). Single-game carries: 40 (vs. Green Bay, November 2006, on a broken foot in the snow). Career 100-yard rushing games: 37. Seasons with 1,000+ rushing yards: 5.
He ranks in the top position in at least 20 career, season, or single-game franchise categories. Marshawn Lynch had the Beastquake run and a Super Bowl ring. He never came close to Alexander’s career totals in Seattle. Chris Warren was the franchise’s pre-Alexander standard. Alexander lapped him.
The Contract, the Broken Foot, and How Quickly It Ended
In March 2006, fresh off the MVP award, Alexander signed an eight-year, $62 million contract – the largest ever given to a running back at the time. Three things happened almost immediately that made the contract look like a mistake.
Steve Hutchinson, the All-Pro left guard who had been a cornerstone of the offensive line, left for the Minnesota Vikings via free agency. In Week 3 of the 2006 season, Alexander broke his left foot. He still came back and set a team record with 40 carries in a snowy Monday Night Football game against the Packers in November – still on the broken foot – and ran for 201 yards. That performance probably convinced people things were fine. They weren’t. He finished 2006 with 896 yards. In 2007, he managed 716.
The Madden curse became a running joke, and fairly so – he was the cover athlete for Madden NFL 2007 and broke his foot in Week 3. But the loss of Hutchinson was structural damage the offense couldn’t absorb. Alexander’s style depended on hitting specific gaps with precision timing. When the blocking changed, so did everything else. He was released in April 2008, signed briefly with Washington, played four games, rushed for 24 yards total, and retired in November. The career was over at 31.
Ring of Honor, 15 Years After His Last Game
On October 16, 2022, Alexander was inducted into the Seahawks Ring of Honor during a home game against the Arizona Cardinals at Lumen Field. He became the 16th member and the third from the 2005 Super Bowl team, joining Hasselbeck and Holmgren, who had gone in the year before. His number 37 now hangs in the rafters.
It had taken nearly 15 years since his last snap. That gap is worth sitting with. By contrast, Steve Largent and Walter Jones were inducted relatively quickly after their careers ended. Alexander’s wait wasn’t explained publicly by the organization, though the fact that his career ended somewhat quietly in Washington rather than triumphantly in Seattle may have contributed to it taking this long. His production declined sharply. Ring of Honor decisions aren’t purely statistical, but the delay was noticeable for the franchise’s only MVP.
When he came back for the ceremony, he talked about what the era meant beyond his own numbers. “We changed the culture,” he said. “Going to the playoffs five years in a row – it created the culture that this is a winning town.” He also spoke about his work with the Matt Talbot Center, a Catholic Community Services addiction recovery and homeless shelter program near the Space Needle. That community engagement, mostly quiet during his playing years, was part of why he was also nominated as the Seahawks’ Walter Payton NFL Man of the Year representative.
The Hall of Fame Argument, Which Is Harder Than It Should Be
Alexander has been a modern-era Hall of Fame nominee nine of the past ten years. He has never reached the semifinalist stage. That gap between the nomination and the actual consideration is the interesting part.
His 100 career rushing touchdowns rank tied for eighth in NFL history. Everyone above him on that list is in the Hall of Fame except Adrian Peterson, who isn’t yet eligible. The six running backs directly behind him are also in the Hall. That context is important and gets overlooked in the discourse: his touchdown total isn’t fringe Hall of Fame – it’s solidly inside the group that voters have consistently recognized as Canton-worthy. His career rushing yards of 9,453 rank 36th all-time, which sounds mediocre until you note that he has more yards than Hall of Famers Earl Campbell, Jim Taylor, Terrell Davis, and Larry Csonka.
The counterargument comes from two directions. First, his prime was compressed. Five excellent seasons and then a significant drop-off. Critics compare him to Curtis Martin, who ran for 14,101 career yards, or to LaDainian Tomlinson, who eclipsed Alexander’s single-season TD record with 31 in 2006 and added 13,684 rushing yards over a longer peak. Second, the offensive line. This one is legitimate but cuts both ways. Yes, Jones and Hutchinson cleared lanes. But Alexander had to see those lanes and make safeties miss in open field, which he demonstrably did. When Hutchinson left and the line changed, Alexander’s production dropped. That’s evidence of system dependence, but it’s also evidence that the system mattered – and he was its engine for five years.
The honest answer is that he belongs in a Hall of Fame argument, and the touchdown numbers specifically are hard to dismiss. Whether voters eventually agree is a different question. He hasn’t been close yet.
Where He Is Now
He’s 48 years old, lives on a farm in the Washington D.C. area with his wife Valerie, and has 12 children. He speaks regularly at churches, youth events, and leadership conferences. His faith has been central to his public identity since his playing days – he was known during his Seahawks career for not celebrating extravagantly, for crediting teammates and God before himself, and for the contrast that created with how most NFL stars operate. Mack Strong said it plainly back then: “Shaun isn’t pumping his chest and gnashing his teeth every time he runs the football, but he’s probably the fiercest competitor on the team.”
He still watches the Seahawks closely. In April 2026, he appeared on Mad Dog Radio ahead of the NFL Draft and offered his view on what Seattle should look for with the 32nd overall pick: “Get the guy that fits well in the culture, and then go get the most talented guy that fits the culture.” Whether it’s a running back or a defensive lineman, he said – get the talent that fits the mentality. The Seahawks won the Super Bowl last season under Mike Macdonald, and Alexander’s fingerprints on the winning-culture argument are, at minimum, part of the franchise’s self-understanding.
He was the first athlete to appear on the cover of both Madden NFL and NCAA Football. The Madden 2007 cover came at the worst possible time commercially and personally, but the NCAA Football 2001 cover – which came out when he was still relatively unknown nationally – was a first that nobody has replicated for a running back since. That’s a strange footnote for a player whose national recognition never quite matched what he actually did on the field, which is maybe the through-line of his whole career: historically productive, chronically underappreciated, still waiting on Canton.
Comments